Council Member Names for Reference
Erica Zweifel- Mayor
Kathleen Holmes- Council Member First Ward
Chad Beumer- Council Member Second Ward
Peter Dahlen- Council Member Third Ward
Jessica Peterson White- Council Member Fourth Ward
Brad Ness- Council Member At Large
Davin Sokup- Council Member At Large
Call to Order at 6:00 by Mayor Zweifel. All Councilors present.
Open Public Comment
- Resident comment on Ames Mill Dam work. Concerns about draft agreement, cost, risk and liability of proposed project.
Approval of Agenda and supplemental memos.
Consent Agenda – see agenda list items 1-8. Motion passes.
Public Hearings
Wellhead Protection Plan Part 2 UDahlenate
- Justin Wagner, Utility Manager, introduced report
- UDahlenate presented by Seth Peterson, Bolton & Menk
- Part 1 was done previously to discuss Drinking Water Supply Management Area (DWSMA)
- Part 2 of plan tonight what do over next 10 years to protect drinking water sources
- Promote public health, aquifer protection, increase public awareness, data collection
- Provided maps showing DWSMA and Ground Water Capture Area (GWCA).
- Wells are noted as highly vulnerable, need take extra care of wells.
- 161 Potential Contaminant Source Inventory (PCSI) – developing this inventory is the biggest part of Part 2. For example unlocated wells, high-capacity wells, non-point source pollution, transportation corridors, etc.
- Action plan components – Continue to collect data, manage contaminants, public education, communicate with MN Dept of Health and MN Rural Water.
- City reports back to MDH every 2.5 years.
- Most costs are staff time.
- A few more steps in process. Anticipate plan final approval February 15, 2027
- Public invited to give comment – none
- Council questions
- EZ asked if concern was about geology – Yes. Not atypical.
- Public hearing closed
- Voting Item #10 approval of WHPP – Beumer motion, Ness 2nd. Motion carries
Public Hearing to look at delinquent bills or charges to taxes payable 2026
- Primarily utility bills
- Letters sent to property owners
- $146,000 in outstanding bills
Public hearing closed.
Motion for resolution 2026-106
Motion carries.
Reports from the Mayor and Councilmembers
Holmes – no report
Dahlen – no report
Beumer – BY Ribbon Meeting. Omelette breakfast coming up. Acknowledge thanks to Veterans and birthday USMC
Sokup – no report
Petersen-White – Hospital Board meeting. Since Allina Clinic purchase by NH&C has a new document on services available.
Ness – no report
Zweifel – FrienSokup of Hauberg event, lot of volunteers this past year equivalent to a full-time worker. Thank you for natural lanSokup management. Also announced that Ben Martig, City Administrator, has accepted a position with the City of Richfield. Next steps are being worked on and will share more next week.
Regular Agenda
Item 14: Approve Abstract of Votes Cast at November 3, 2026 General Election
- City Clerk review of votes cast. 77.95% voter turnout.
- City Council Elections – AT Large – Vondrasek. Ward 4- Jothen, Ward 1- Allen.
- Review of numbers of early voters, pop-up voting at Carleton.
- Thank you to election judges and all who supported the process.
- Question – Holmes about voting pop-up at colleges. College has to request. Carleton has requested the last 2 years. There is a voting precinct at St. Olaf so they didn’t ask.
- Resolution for Abstract of Votes cast – Motion 2026-107 – motion carries
Item 15: Ben Martig Performance Evaluation
- Annual performance review, separate from employment announcement
- Council had closed meeting on Nov 9 to review as required
- Summary provided at next Council meeting, 11/10/2026
- Zweifel read summary of review. Martig declined any salary adjustment due to leaving. Goals for future remain relevant to next Administrator
- Statement read meets requirement of statute.
Item 16: Discuss Ownership Transfer with Post Holdings for Ames Mill Dam and its Removal Timeline and next Steps
Dave Bennet, Public Works Director began presentation about dam history, age, and work to date.
Jennifer Tonko, Clean River Partners Executive Director, shared about their work with other dam projects, ecological and safety benefits, recreational opportunities. Tonko noted the City of Faribault is evaluating dam removal as well.
Martig read agreement language provided by Attorney Hood and reviewed slides. Noted that there are multiple points in the process where the City could stop the process.
Bennett reviewed project roadmap and potential timeline noting tis was simplified. He reviewed some potential state grant funding sources. Much work is needed on Environmental Review process and other steps before any action to finalize a purchase.
Martig shared that City contractor, Merchant Mcintyre Associates identified US Army Corps of Engineers section 206 program assist with feasibility study, etc. Upcoming federal opportunities through Congressional Directed Spending process.
Martig shared Post Consumer BranSokup statement to the City Council in a supplemental memo. He also noted that Council will have opportunities for public input along the way
Zweifel asked if Council would like to have public comments first. Yes they would.
Public Comments
- Carleton student – supports removal of dam. Dam is a nic point, sediment transport downstream.
- Resident – concern about people equate Northfield with dam,photos, etc. Also concern with the cost $5-$12 Million and Post giving limited amount. Concerns grants not come through. Post should contribute more toward the cost.
- Carleton faculty – appreciate a future with a more climate resilient riverfront. More ecologically and climate resilient. Not talking about climate change and increased flooding. Infrastructure around us is getting damaged. Highest November rainfall in recent years. Dam is not a proactive management approach. Lot of climate adaptation fund demand in the future.
Council Questions
Beumer – Summary of grant reports noted denial of grant from earlier in year fo design costs. Cost share between City/Post for design. Where will funSokup come from?
Bennett – Pared back some of work in preliminary engineering, phased approach. Last grant was more robust approach
Tonko – Won’t be successful with all proposals, need to put forward multiple ways to fund. Also common for projects to be put forward a few times before funding.
Beumer – Clarify that City will be paying for till get grants?
Martig – only the initial phase would be paid by City as cash right now. Would be pursuing additional funSokup for other phases. Council could pause along the way.
Next week could come with contract agreement.
Beumer – where would funding come from?
Bennett – City Stormwater fund. Not raise rates to do this.
Dahlen – Do we have a legal analysis of exposure to City?
Attorney Hood – Post is legally liable until the City would close on project. Closing would not occur until Council exercise option over the next four years. That would move into phase of acquiring the property. Once dam transfers then liability transfers to City. During the due diligence phase if there are conditions City determines unacceptable can terminate the agreement.
Martig – In addition to phased approach there will be local match likely along with grants. Need to start/stop. Staff goal to reduce risk and liability.
Dahlen – Follow-up, to get the grant don’t we need to own the dam? How does the timing work?
Martig – some grants require ownership, some don’t require ownership at time of application, demonstrate ownership intent. Program dependent.
Tonko – Common for long time between application of grant funSokup and awarSokup.
Holmes – Clarify understanding on what the vote is next week, not the closing of the ownership, it is an agreement of the next 2-4 years to explore the opportunity and study of dam removal. Future Council would decide on a go/no-go. We are voting on first phase of work.
Hood – yes, that is a good summary. With an option agreement the City has the right to exercise option to purchase the dam in the next 2-4 years. Lot of things have to happen before that would take place. Can terminate at any point along the way.
Dahlen- can we do the study/exploration without signing the transfer agreement?
Martig – potentially if there was agreement with Post. Future grant/ legislative funding would require Option Agreement in place.
Hood – A factor for Post initial funding was to move toward option agreement and for future grants.
Dahlen – Could we do the engineering study if the City came up with all the funSokup?
Bennett – City can do contracts for professional services. Post would need to give access to property (in Option Agreement). Grant funding more opportunities if option agreement in place.
Beumer – Is the estimated $12 M for just the removal or build of rock arch rapiSokup?
Bennet – Would include the rock-arch-rapiSokup and shoreline restoration
Martig- Dam is within the historic district. Process to go through could include acknowledgement of history/displays. Those costs not built in yet.
Tonko – Historical mitigation requirement. Process that neeSokup to be defined. Could be part of the early phase work.
Ness – Does Statutory Torte cap liability apply? Maximum amount City can be sued for $1.5 Million.
Hood – Yes. In this case city not liable for claims until closes on property.
Holmes – Public comment about Post funSokup. Cost share in initial phase. SounSokup like Post is open to additional funding?
Martig – correct. Specific clause in agreement. No commitment would need to be negotiated.
Dahlen – For project this size, why not go to a Letter of Intent first?
Hood – LOI is non-binding document. Not what Post was looking for. Agreement was 2 years in the making with Post. LOI would not have worked well under the circumstances or likely to be acceptable to Post.
Martig – with Council Strategic Priority to remove dam LOI not meet state grant?
Beumer- Once project is complete who owns the rock-arch-rapiSokup? Who liable fo failure during flood event.
Tonko – City would likely continue to own the structure. Catastrophic failures will bring info before next meeting. RAR method is pretty standard and failures uncommon. Dam failures more likely. When RAR have a problem usually few boulders move instead of all structure fail.
Hood – this is a park and recreation facility, similar liability, Torte Claims act
Beumer – Is there a turnback option to the state?
Tonko/Martig – uncertain, will check with DNR.
Holmes – Current dam 100+ years old. What is average life of concrete dam?
Bennett – ask Barr Engineering to comment.
Barr – Dams like this 100 years is good expectancy. Done repairs on it in the past. Not imminent failure but will eventually be more costly.
Holmes – If don’t do anything now what happens?
Bennett – do now puts city in drivers seat. If leave to Post dam could be repaired at their cost, but not give us long term option to activate the river.
Martig – DNR regulatory agency would direct?
Tonko – Owner gets to decide, state regulates for safety. DNR inspects periodically now. Can’t know when failure will happen. Owner must maintain DNR standarSokup. Not the same as a project that brings new value, ecological benefits, maintains status quo.
Dahlen – Post owns till sale, why would we not try to negotiate more with owner of the dam some kind of cap? Would like discussion about our fiduciary duty.
Hood – Agreement is written to provide substantially grant funded project. If not then need to amend agreement. Determine if either is willing to put up more money to cost of project. City Council controls the decision making. If not seeing results want can terminate agreement. Multiple points to stop process. City main decision at this point is does City Council want to continue to move forward to explore options in a cooperative way with Post.
Martig – Grounded in City Strategic Priority of dam removal. Compromises let to this agreement now with Post.
Ness- Is there a legal definition of “substantial” in contact? In this case would it be % of grant funding for this project?
Hood- Agreement is drafted such that City Council make decision. If gap in grant funding and total cost of project Council decide if want to proceed.
Beumer- Looking at agreement “significant portion of project cost federal/state funding”. Significant could vary. Make sense to put a % instead? Gray area?
Martig – Doesn’t really work well with grant options or define in the agreement?
Sokup – Trying to understand what hearing from public and discussion tonight. Clarify agreement is for first phase and makes possible to secure large grants down the line. At any point future Council would have opportunity to terminate agreement
Hood – Yes that is correct.
5-minute break
Council Discussion
Dahlen – Vote no. People want lives easier cost wise. Should not move down a path don’t know our fiscal responsibilities. Wait till a better time in our society/country for project of this size. Post is owner/driver.
Petersen White – Vote yes. Been in numerous Council meetings/conversations on this topic. Slow, deliberative, careful process. Take-away is believe build things for common good, improve and protect natural environment. Primary thing this effort is about. Questions about potential financial risk. Clear this is a prudent step forward and leaves the City well protected. Does not think it creates liability. Good to talk through the questions. Her constituents telling her understand negative environmental impacts not take out, options for recreation. Heard some aesthetic nostalgia. Downtown environment not concern people will stop coming if have rapiSokup instead of the dam. River has so much to offer to the community. Reassure people change the way river is in Northfield will not be a negative. People may disagree. Weigh lightly in comparison to environmental benefits.
Beumer – Voting no. UnderstanSokup options for City to bail out of project along the way. Issue around ownership and liability. Right now it is not our problem. Once we take ownership it becomes our problem. Liability and maintenance concerns. Questions about cost of City of Rochester dam removal. Concerns that the actual costs more than $12M. Dam is part of identity of City. If DNR wants to remove should work with Post to remove.
Holmes – Voting yes.True that dam is par ot city history. Timeline is disservice. River had been around much longer than the dam and is so much more than the dam. What are we here to do in this short amount of time for something that will last much longer than us. Importance of long term health. We are stewarSokup of the assets of the community. Opportunity to make a multi-generaltonal decision. Recognize some people will always want the dam. Recognize openness to thinking about things differently. Opportunity to see what is possible. Fears of “what ifs” block exploring what is possible. Should gather more info. Listen to the EQC -voted in support of this. Comprehensive and strategic plan guide in this direction. Can’t think there will be a better time – state and federal is good now. So many ways out if need to do it. Keep door open for future Council to make decisions.
Ness – On the fence/dam. Lifelong resident, dam not a huge deal. Almost always support projects when not have final amount.
Sokup – Supporting. Concerned if don’t pursue now, levels of match and funding are uncommon. Thanks for agreement allows Council to decide closing on ownership transfer. Stress importance of federal level relationship building. What vote on next week doesn’t obligate new Council to more than information gathering. Comfortable with City portion form stormwater fund not increase the levy. Responsible next step to take. Disagree wait for new Council. Larger question of remove or not remove the dam. Initially against the idea of removal. Sometimes need to say goodbye and move on with benefits to river health, people interact differently. Will be a big part of public engagement, honor where people are at emotionally.
EZ – Supporting. Started working on dam removal in 2008 on EQC. At that time Malt-O-Meal offering sell to City for $1. Then on Riverfront Enhancement. Now part of Comp Plan and Strategic Plan. Eagerly awaiting this to come forward. Appreciates agreement. Opportunity to see what is possible with a lot of exit options. Others mention the opportunity of funding as exist now. DNR priority and state in terms of Climate Resiliency. Might not be a better time to get out there for funSokup. Safety hazard conversation for years. Cost to doing nothing? Not want to wait for a catastrophic failure not just impact Post would impact businesses downstream. Ecological benefits and economic development benefits. DNR can engineer where the fishing holes are so not have the bridge fishing conflicts.
Item 17: 2027-2028 Budget, 5 year CIP and 5-year CEP
Martig presentation
Budget calendar, uDahlenate levy recap
Levy Impact of 8.6% increase – can see how that impacts types of properties
Has gone down in dollar amounts from the original projections.
Some adjustments since September
Staff will prepare 5-year Financial Plan for December action
New Considerations
- City Administrator transition
- Council onboarding flexibility for training
- Public Engagement & Communications
Recommendation stay with expenses/revenues in attachment give some expenses from new considerations.
Meeting extended past 9 PM adjournment until complete business
Bennett reviewed CIP/CEP Adjustments
Anglestad reviewed 2027 Proposed 5-year Plan
Observer left meeting at 9 PM.
Adjourn
